Language Exercises (Being Precise and Clear)




Exercise Contents
Writing Workbook
Writing Courses

Language Exercises:
Being Familiar
Being Concise
Being Fluid


Click on the main precision or clarity problem in each of the following sentences. This exercise is important because if you can precisely identify writing problems, you are in a much better position to identify solutions. Specific problems are as follows:
  1. Precision problem (pages 73-82)
  2. Clarity problem: Needless Complexity (pages 83-90)
  3. Clarity problem: ambiguity (pages 90-96)
If you are unsure about the category, click on the place in the sentence where the specific problem occurs. The numbers in parentheses refer to pages in The Craft of Scientific Writing that provide corresponding information.





  1. On that flight, the right booster's aft field joint's primary O-ring eroded 0.053 inches.

    Imprecision
    Needless Complexity
    Ambiguity
    No precision or clarity problem







































    #1. Congratulations, you have found the main problem.

    Clarity problem: needlessly complex phrase. The modifier string ("the right booster's aft field joint's primary O-ring") is too long for the reader to comprehend in one pass.

    Possible solution: Break up the string ("the primary O-ring on the aft field joint of the right booster..."). For further discussion, see pages 85-86.



    Top of Page



  2. Within the master control there are four computers and approximately 1943 microprocessors.

    Imprecision
    Needless Complexity
    Ambiguity
    No precision or clarity problem






































    #2. Congratulations, you have found the main problem.

    Precision problem: imprecise level of detail. Given the use of "approximately," the number of microprocessors is overspecified.

    Possible solutions: Either make the number less specific ("about two thousand microprocessors") or cut the modifier ("Within the master control there are four computers and 1943 microprocessors"). For further discussion, see pages 80-81.



    Top of Page



  3. The proposed schedule is discussed below for the next four years.

    Imprecision
    Needless Complexity
    Ambiguity
    No precision or clarity problem






































    #3. Congratulations, you have found the main problem.

    Clarity problem: ambiguity arising from syntax. Was the schedule discussed for four years or was there a four-year schedule?

    Possible solution: Move the prepositional phrase ("The proposed four-year schedule is discussed below"). For further discussion, see pages 92-93.



    Top of Page



  4. The beams are positioned with respect to the chopper blade so that while one beam passes the output of the opposite beam is completely blocked.

    Imprecision
    Needless Complexity
    Ambiguity
    No precision or clarity problem






































    #4. Congratulations, you have found the main problem.

    Clarity problem: ambiguity arising from punctuation problem. The reader trips thinking that one beam has passed the output of the opposite beam.

    Solution: Place a comma after word "passes." For further discussion, see pages 94-96.



    Top of Page



  5. The goal of the silver/polymer reflector research is to develop and verify the technical feasibility of at least one durable silver/polymer reflector material for use in constructing low-cost, lightweight concentrators--a material that is resistant to ultraviolet radiation, resistant to pollution attack, has a specular reflectance of greater than 90 percent, a specularity comparable to that for silver/glass mirrors, and a useful life of at least 15 years.

    Imprecision
    Needless Complexity
    Ambiguity
    No precision or clarity problem






































    #5. Congratulations, you have found the main problem.

    Clarity problem: needlessly complex sentence. The sentence contains too many ideas.

    Possible solution: Break up the sentence into two or three sentences. First revision: "The goal of this research on silver/polymer reflectors is to develop and test at least one durable material for use in a low-cost, lightweight concentrator. This reflector material must be resistant to ultraviolet radiation and pollution attack. It must also have a useful life of 15 years and a specular reflectance of greater than 90 percent, which is comparable to that for silver/glass mirrors." For further discussion, see pages 86-90.



    Top of Page



  6. The Lunar Module was only designed to hold two astronauts and to have a life time of forty-five hours.

    Imprecision
    Needless Complexity
    Ambiguity
    No precision or clarity problem






































    #6. Congratulations, you have found the main problem.

    Clarity problem: ambiguity arising from syntax. The placement of the word "only" causes an ambiguity. Was the lunar module designed for only two purposes (to hold two astronauts and to exist for forty-five hours)? Or was the lunar module designed to hold only two astronauts? )? Or was the lunar module designed to exist for only forty-five hours?

    Possible solution: Rethink the position and use of the word "only." First revision: "The Lunar Module was designed to accommodate at most two astronauts and to operate at most for forty-five hours." For further discussion, see pages 92-93.



    Top of Page



  7. A physician named Irving Selikoff credited asbestos with causing two types of lung cancer: asbestosis and mesothelioma.

    Imprecision
    Needless Complexity
    Ambiguity
    No precision or clarity problem






































    #7. Congratulations, you have found the main problem.

    Precision problem: imprecise word choice. The word "credited" has a positive connation, which is out of place in the sentence.

    Possible solution: Replace the word "credited" with the word "blamed." Revision: "A physician named Irving Selikoff blamed asbestos with causing two types of lung cancer: asbestosis and mesothelioma." For further discussion, see pages 77-78.



    Top of Page



  8. Scientists at the biosphere had to deal with problems ranging from pest invasions to lack of oxygen. Because of this, the project has begun to accept offers for researchers to enter the dome for anywhere from a few days to several months.

    Imprecision
    Needless Complexity
    Ambiguity
    No precision or clarity problem






































    #8. Congratulations, you have found the main problem.

    Clarity problem: ambiguity arising from pronoun. What does the word "this" refer to? Only the writer knows for sure. Note that this problem could be considered a discontinuity (see pages 137-138).

    Possible solution: Add specific details that help make the transition from the problems encountered to the decision about the length of time that researchers can work in the biosphere. For further discussion, see pages 92-93.



    Top of Page



  9. Enormous, high-tech, modern mining companies are both continuing operations at old gold mines, such as the case of the Homestake Mine in Lead, South Dakota, which has operated continuously since 1877 and is continuing to increase its operations [Hinds and Trautman, 1983], and opening new gold mines, often in very disturbing locations, such as the proposed, and for now, postponed, New World Mine, whose proposed location was about 2.5 miles from the border of Yellowstone National Park, near Cooke City, Montana.

    Imprecision
    Needless Complexity
    Ambiguity
    No precision or clarity problem






































    #9. Congratulations, you have found the main problem.

    Clarity problem: needlessly complex sentence. The sentence contains too many ideas (reflected by the number of parenthetical commas).

    Possible solution: Break up the sentence into two or three sentences. First revision: "Modern mining companies, which are enormous and high-tech, are both continuing operations at old gold mines and opening new ones. An example of an old gold mine is the Homestake Mine in Lead, South Dakota. This mine has operated continuously since 1877 and is continuing to increase its operations [Hinds and Trautman, 1983]. An example of a new gold mine is the proposed New World Mine, which is to be about 2.5 miles from the border of Yellowstone National Park, near Cooke City, Montana. The construction of this mine has been postponed." For further discussion, see pages 86-90.



    Top of Page



  10. If an airplane waits too long to take off the de-icing fluid can dissipate.

    Imprecision
    Needless Complexity
    Ambiguity
    No precision or clarity problem






































    #10. Congratulations, you have found the main problem.

    Clarity problem: ambiguity arising from punctuation problem. The reader trips thinking that the airplane has waited too long to take off de-icing fluid.

    Possible solution: Place a comma after word "off." For further discussion, see pages 94-96.



    Top of Page



    You have reached the end of this exercise.




Last updated 2/99
http://www.me.vt.edu/writing/exercises/
http://ae3.cen.uiuc.edu/writing/exercises/
All materials at this web site are the intellectual property of the editors and authors. You are more than welcome to make hypertext links to these pages as long as proper credit is given. If you have comments, suggestions, or questions, please direct them to one of the editors.